
Nestlé Told Us It Couldn't Be Done. Then They Bought Us. | Carter Comstock, Alberto Lopez Toledo
Mike Wystrach, Carter Comstock and Alberto Lopez Toledo took Freshly from 2am shifts in a restaurant kitchen to more than a million fresh, never-frozen meals a week, and in 2020 Nestlé bought it for up to $1.5 billion. This is the first time the three co-founders have told the story together. Carter slept on a duct-taped air mattress, an 80-year-old pool hustler offered to double his check on one game, and Nestlé, Alberto remembers, said fresh couldn't be done. This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantage Follow Mike on Instagram: @mikewystrach — https://instagram.com/mikewystrach In this episode: ◼ How a $2,000 steak dinner raised $100,000 from friends and family ◼ Why customers who loved the food kept forgetting to order, and how a subscription fixed it ◼ Why they shipped fresh: there was no money for a blast freezer ◼ Where the money went, and how Freshly outgrew a rival Mike says raised four times more ◼ The panic attack Mike had in front of Highland Capital's partners, and what Bob Davis did next If you are building something hard and wondering whether it is supposed to feel this way, this one is for you. ⏱️ CHAPTERS 00:00 Ep 15: The Freshly Founders Reunite 01:31 Why Carter Quit His Job 07:51 2am Shifts, One Air Mattress 10:46 The Worst Brand Ever 14:21 The Subscription Bet 18:42 The Pool Hustler Investor 31:28 Closing a CTO Over Breakfast 36:42 Day One: Last In at 9am 38:51 Charging Cards by Hand 50:07 Raising 4x Less Than the Rival 53:18 COVID's Darkest Week 64:46 The Highland Panic Attack 73:45 Three Years or Three Months 76:35 Nestlé Said It Can't Be Done 83:54 Advice Every Founder Needs 95:01 Final Thoughts and Wrap Up 🔗 CARTER COMSTOCK & ALBERTO LOPEZ TOLEDO Cityblock Health (Alberto, CTO) → https://www.cityblock.com Cutting Horse → https://www.cuttinghorse.com 🎙️ THE ADVANTAGE Apple Podcasts → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-advantage-with-mike-wystrach/id6783458081 Spotify → https://open.spotify.com/show/033DuFkyBRu3qvgp8ozPz1 All episodes → https://mikewystrach.com/podcast ⚡ PRESENTED BY PROPPEL Proppel places marketing and operations talent from the US, LATAM and beyond, from video editors, designers and media buyers to managers, directors and VPs. It's performance-based: a one-off fee only when you hire, no retainers, and a three-month guarantee on every hire. Get 10% off your first hire → https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantage #Freshly #CarterComstock #AlbertoLopezToledo #Nestle #TheAdvantage
- Transcript
