AI Killed the Resume. Here’s What Gets You Hired Now | Peter Zotto, Trove | EP.31
When Peter Zotto sold ProfitWell to Paddle for $200 million in 2022, most people expected him to go quiet. He didn't. He spent two years at Paddle, missed building something from scratch, and ran into a problem nobody had solved: how do you show what you've actually done? His LinkedIn said he sold a company. His resume didn't say much more. So he built Trove, a place to prove your impact through the eyes of the people who worked with you. I brought Peter on because he wrote one of the best definitions of reputation I've heard: "The proof someone is excellent is trapped in other people's memories." Think about where your best work lives today. A client email. A shoutout from your boss in Slack. A reference call (Peter still gets one from a former ProfitWell colleague almost every week). When ProfitWell got acquired, every Drive and Slack got shut off on day one, and years of proof were gone overnight. Now AI makes every resume look polished and every candidate look the same. "Led sales" doesn't tell anyone anything. Recruiters want the how. We talked about why a big exit doesn't mean you're done (he still drives a used 2020 Jeep Cherokee), why consumer is so much harder than B2B, the hiring mistake with ex-HubSpot reps that taught him to always ask how someone hit quota, and how ProfitWell became "the Bloomberg of SaaS" with its own studio, a full media team and pricing page teardowns that made it all the way to executives and investors. What you'll learn Why Peter went back into startups after a $200M exit, and why he still feels he has something to prove How Trove captures the how behind your wins and who helped you get there, not just the outcome Why consumer is harder than B2B, when people who scroll for hours call a 45-second onboarding "too much work" Why nobody is thinking about you as much as you think (and why that should make posting easier) Where your career proof lives right now, and why it disappears the day you leave Why AI-written resumes all look alike and get filtered out before a human sees them How to tell a hunter from an order taker, and why "Led sales" isn't enough The ProfitWell hiring mistake with ex-HubSpot reps, and the same trap companies fall into with CMOs How ProfitWell ran hyper-personalized video campaigns with a custom landing page for every prospect How pricing page teardowns turned content into sales conversations Why it's never been easier to hit $1M ARR and never been harder to grow past it Rapid fire: the best hire Peter ever made (and almost fired in week one), whether to kill cover letters, the cold outreach move that gets VCs to reply, and what reputation means to him Timestamps 00:00 Why Start a Company Again After an Exit 01:01 What Is Trove? Proving Your Career Impact 05:17 Life After Selling ProfitWell for $200M 09:08 Consumer vs B2B: Which Is Harder? 14:17 Imposter Syndrome as a Founder 17:27 Why Reputation Lives in Other People's Memories 21:12 The Vibes Tax in Hiring 23:18 Show Your Work, Not Just Results 24:20 Hiring for the How, Not the Title 27:37 AI Resumes and the Hiring Arms Race 30:10 How ProfitWell Built a Media Machine 32:54 Content That Drives Sales 36:42 Founder-Led Marketing on LinkedIn 37:55 Rapid Fire: Best Hire and Cover Letters 43:39 What Reputation Really Means 46:28 Where to Find Trove GUEST Peter Zotto, Founder of Trove and Co-founder of ProfitWell. Trove: https://thetrove.io/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/peterzotto/ HOST Justin Obey, founder of Obey Creative. We help B2B founders turn cold outbound into warm conversations through a podcast-driven content engine. One episode per week. Your prospects know and trust you before your sales team ever picks up the phone. First episode live in 30 days. LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/justinobey/ Website: https://obeycreative.com/ SHOW Return on Reputation explores how founders and business leaders turn expertise into trust, authority, relationships and business growth. Subscribe to Return on Reputation for more conversations about personal branding, leadership and building a business people trust.