
Won't Fix Episode 21: Nate Persily, The James B. McClatchy Professor of Law at Stanford Law School
A week after the 2026 midterms, we dig into what AI did and didn't do in the election. In Nate's view, AI mattered more as an issue than ever before, especially through the fight over data centers, but the feared wave of vote-swinging deepfakes never came. We talk about what regulation looks like now that AI isn't a partisan issue but still faces a presidential veto, and why, as Nate puts it, "if you go into the OpenAI cafeteria, the food is more regulated than the models that they produce." He explains why PATA still matters but isn't enough ("it's not enough to just essentially fight the last war"), and what transparency could look like when chatbot conversations happen in private. We also get into the open-model problem and how to get defenders access to frontier AI, who's liable when AI defames someone or an agent goes rogue, whether we need an FDA for AI, and why "there's pretty much nothing that a young lawyer can do that an AI cannot do better at this point." In this episode: AI for, in and through politics: what the midterms told us Data centers as the outlet for people's AI anxiety Where AI regulation is headed: states, attorneys general and a consensus among the labs China, open-weight models, and a government-sanctioned pathway for security defenders PATA, the "last war," and new ideas for AI transparency, such as letting users donate their chats to research Section 230, AI defamation and who's liable for AI agents An FDA for AI, and the government's talent gap How AI is transforming law firms, legal training and the courts Resources & Links: Watch Nate's recent talk, "The Politics of AI" (Stanford Law AI Initiative, Oct. 1, 2026): https://youtu.be/HfLRKkEDog4 Nate's Stanford Law faculty page: https://law.stanford.edu/nathaniel-persily/ Stanford Law AI Initiative: https://law.stanford.edu/ai APSA AI task force volume, How Will AI Reshape Politics?: https://law.stanford.edu/press/how-will-ai-reshape-politics-new-volume-co-edited-by-stanford-laws-nathaniel-persily-explores-the-stakes/ The Platform Accountability and Transparency Act (S. 3292): https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/3292 Nate's website: https://www.persily.com Chapter Timestamps: 00:00 Introduction 1:48 AI as an election issue, especially through data centers 3:43 Campaign AI, political ads, and whether deepfakes changed votes 5:13 Everyday AI use and the challenge of drawing regulatory boundaries 7:24 Bipartisan support, federal barriers, and state-level regulation 11:16 Industry governance, safety concerns, and data-center opposition 14:32 China, open models, and access for safety researchers 18:31 PATA and the case for independent research access 23:24 What AI transparency should measure 30:16 Section 230, AI-generated content, and liability for harm 33:49 AI agents, transactions, and responsibility when something goes wrong 39:05 Possible federal AI oversight and the need for public expertise 41:22 AI’s effects on law firms, legal education, and junior lawyers 45:14 Court backlogs, judicial use of AI, and closing reflections