Skip to content
Artwork for So Near Yet So VAR
SportsSoccer

So Near Yet So VAR

with Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden

No corporate FA filters. No dodging the hard questions. Every single week, we are giving you a direct, honest breakdown of the biggest refereeing and VAR decisions across English and Scottish football inside 30 minutes.

Episodes drop Sunday evenings at 2200.

Play
  • 12 episodes
  • weekly
  • Avg 42 min
  • English
  • S1 · E10
    November 9 · 50 min

    HAVERTZ DENIED A CLEAR PENALTY?! #footballpodcast #sonearyetsovar #refereecontroversy #vardebate

    🚨 PENRICE WINS A CONTROVERSIAL PENALTY! HAVERTZ DENIED ONE?! | So Near, Yet So VARFormer FIFA-accredited referees Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden are back to analyse another weekend of controversial VAR decisions, penalty incidents, red cards and refereeing talking points from the English Premier League and Scottish Premiership.⚖️ THIS WEEK'S BIGGEST TALKING POINTS:🔵 ST MIRREN 0-2 RANGERS: JAMES PENRICE WINS A SOFT PENALTY?Rangers are awarded a controversial first-half penalty after James Penrice goes down under minimal contact from St Mirren's Samuel Ramos. Referee Nick Walsh points to the spot and VAR Greg Aitken allows the decision to stand. Was it a clear penalty, or did Penrice make the most of the contact? Bobby Madden and Mark Clattenburg give their verdicts.🔴 ARSENAL vs HULL: KAI HAVERTZ DENIED A CLEAR PENALTY?!The major talking point of the weekend! Hull defender Nobel Mendy pulls Kai Havertz's shirt inside the penalty area, but after a VAR review, referee Farai Hallam overturns the penalty decision and awards Hull a free-kick for offside. Was this a major misunderstanding of the offside law? Can a player be penalised for offside before committing an active offside offence? And did Arsenal get a penalty decision completely wrong? Arsenal eventually win 1-0 through Martin Ødegaard.⚪ LEEDS vs TOTTENHAM: SHOULD JAYDEN BOGLE HAVE SEEN RED?Jayden Bogle catches Mathys Tel around the Achilles with his studs, but VAR Tony Harrington backs the on-field decision. Tottenham are reportedly seeking answers over the incident. We also examine Mateus Fernandes' early handball appeal.🔵 SUNDERLAND vs CHELSEA: TWO CONTROVERSIAL PENALTY DECISIONSCole Palmer goes down after contact from Luke O'Nien, but no penalty is awarded, with VAR judging the contact to be outside the box. At the other end, Brian Brobbey wins a penalty against Levi Colwill. Were both decisions correct?🔵 EVERTON vs COVENTRY: TARKOWSKI HAIR-PULL CONTROVERSYJames Tarkowski appears to pull Caleb Yirenkyi's hair inside the penalty area, but Coventry are not awarded a penalty. Why did VAR stay out of it?🔴 BRIGHTON vs BRENTFORD: IGOR THIAGO SENT OFFMichael Oliver upgrades Thiago's yellow card to a straight red after VAR review for catching Andrés in the face. Was the dismissal justified?🍀 CELTIC vs KILMARNOCK: GOAL OVERTURNED BY VARKasper Høgh's goal is ruled out following a pitchside review for a foul by Mika Baur on Greg Kiltie. Was it a soft decision? We also look at Baur's disallowed goal for offside.🎙️ EXPERT ANALYSIS FROM MARK CLATTENBURG & BOBBY MADDENFrom controversial penalties and shirt pulls to offside interpretations, handballs and red cards, our former FIFA-accredited referees explain the Laws of the Game and give their expert verdicts.Timestamp:00:00:00 - 00:01:02 Intro00:01:02 - 00:06:32 Havertz Penalty Debate00:06:32 - 00:09:05 Fernandes Handball00:09:05 - 00:12:24 Bogle challenge on Tel00:12:24 - 00:17:08 James Tarkowski handful of hair00:17:08 - 00:19:34 Thiago sees RED00:19:34 - 00:22:19 Cole Palmer denied a pen00:22:19 - 00:27:22 Are English Refs relying TOO MUCH on VAR?00:27:22 - 00:33:22 Brobbey's controversial penalty00:33:22 - 00:34:57 Raith v Dunfermline: Pars miss out on a Penalty: Neil Lennon's reaction00:34:57 - 00:38:38 Best and worst stadiums to referee at00:38:38 - 00:40:32 Bobby's trip to Saudi00:40:32 - 00:46:42 Does Penrice con the ref?00:46:42 - 00:47:57 Høgh's disallowed goal00:47:57 - 00:49:28 Tshibola handball. Penalty to Celtic00:49:28 - 00:50:18 Outro💬 JOIN THE DEBATE!Was Kai Havertz robbed of a penalty? Did James Penrice win a soft spot-kick? Which refereeing decision was the biggest mistake of the weekend?Leave your verdict in the comments!👍 LIKE, SUBSCRIBE and turn on notifications for more expert VAR analysis, Premier League refereeing controversies and Scottish football decision reviews.So Near, Yet So VAR – the decisions, the debate and the expert verdict.

  • November 2 · 47 min

    PENRICE ESCAPES RED! 🟥 🤯 ISAK DENIED A PENALTY?! | Clattenburg & Madden #var #refereecontroversy

    From a potential penalty for Liverpool’s Alexander Isak to a shocking high kick at Hampden, we ask: Are referees and VAR getting the big decisions right?Welcome back to So Near Yet So VAR, the football show where controversial refereeing decisions are put under the microscope!This week, former FIFA-accredited referees Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden break down the biggest VAR controversies, red cards, penalty claims and missed decisions from a dramatic weekend of football across the Scottish Premiership and the English Premier League.🔴 THIS WEEK’S BIGGEST TALKING POINTS:🥋 RANGERS vs ABERDEEN: JAMES PENRICE’S KUNG FU KICK!Madness at Hampden as Rangers’ James Penrice launches a high, rib-level kick into Aberdeen midfielder Afeez Aremu — but escapes without even a yellow card, and VAR does not intervene. Should Penrice have been sent off? We also examine two controversial handball incidents involving Rangers’ Dujon Sterling and Aberdeen’s Ayoub Mouloua.🤯 LIVERPOOL DENIED A PENALTY? ISAK VS TIMBERLiverpool’s Alexander Isak appears to be pulled back by Arsenal defender Jurriën Timber, but no penalty is awarded and VAR does not intervene. Does this decision punish players who stay on their feet and avoid theatrics, while rewarding those who make a bigger fuss?🟥 LISANDRO MARTÍNEZ’S ELBOW ON WESLEY FOFANAManchester United are reduced to ten men after Lisandro Martínez receives a second yellow card for an off-the-ball elbow on Chelsea’s Wesley Fofana. Was the dismissal justified, and what does it mean for United and manager Michael Carrick?✋ COVENTRY CITY vs SUNDERLAND: HANDBALL PENALTY DEBATECoventry defender Ethan Pinnock is penalised for handball inside the box. Was the decision correct, or was this another controversial penalty call?🟥 CRYSTAL PALACE’S EARLY RED CARD AGAINST TOTTENHAMJean-Philippe Mateta is initially shown yellow for a late, studs-up challenge on Micky van de Ven, catching the Tottenham defender around the heel and Achilles. VAR recommends a review, and referee Michael Oliver upgrades the card to red. Was the intervention right?🤚 MANCHESTER CITY vs BRIGHTON: PENALTY DENIED!Manchester City lose 1–0 at home to Brighton, but the handball decision involving Luka Vušković sparks debate. Referee Farai Hallam reviews the incident at the monitor and sticks with his original decision. Should City have had a penalty?🟨 MOTHERWELL vs ST MIRREN: VAR SPOTS THE HANDBALLA handball involving St Mirren’s Henry Fieldson requires VAR intervention as Motherwell claim a 1–0 victory. Did the officials get the final decision right?🟥 KILMARNOCK vs ST JOHNSTONE: GOALKEEPER SENT OFFSt Johnstone goalkeeper Toby Steward is dismissed in the 13th minute after rushing outside his penalty area and handling the ball while dealing with a long pass towards Joe Hugill. Was the red card inevitable?⚖️ EXPERT ANALYSIS FROM MARK CLATTENBURG & BOBBY MADDENOur former FIFA-accredited referees examine the laws of the game, explain the key incidents and give their verdicts on the decisions everyone is talking about.💬 JOIN THE DEBATE!Which decision was the biggest refereeing mistake of the weekend? Should James Penrice have seen red? Was Alexander Isak denied a clear penalty? Tell us what you think in the comments.👍 Like the video, subscribe to So Near Yet So VAR, and turn on notifications for more expert analysis of VAR controversies, red cards, penalty decisions and refereeing across Scottish and English football.👉 Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR#SoNearYetSoVAR #VAR #JamesPenrice #Rangers #Liverpool #AlexanderIsak #PremierLeague #ScottishFootball #MarkClattenburg #BobbyMadden

  • October 26 · 52 min

    Diop GETS AWAY WITH ONE? | Palmer & Rogers LOSE THE PLOT | Rangers' Raskin benefits from RED CARD

    Should Chelsea have finished with NINE men against Tottenham? Was Issa Diop lucky to escape a red card? And did Kai Fotheringham's challenge on Rangers' Nicolas Raskin really merit a straight RED card? 👀⚽Welcome back to So Near, Yet So VAR, the show where we break down the biggest VAR controversies, refereeing decisions, red cards, penalty incidents and offside calls from across the football world!This week, we're analysing some huge talking points, questioning the officials' decisions, and asking the question every football fan wants answered: Did the referee and VAR get it right?🔴 ISSA DIOP ESCAPES A RED CARD! IPSWICH TOWN vs NOTTINGHAM FORESTThe biggest talking point of the week! Ipswich Town defender Issa Diop received just a yellow card after fouling James McAtee during a 1–1 draw with Nottingham Forest. But should Diop have been sent off for denying a clear goal-scoring opportunity (DOGSO)?Was the referee correct to show yellow, or was this a major refereeing error? We examine the incident and debate whether VAR should have intervened.🔵 SHOULD CHELSEA HAVE BEEN DOWN TO NINE MEN AGAINST TOTTENHAM?Cole Palmer found himself at the centre of controversy during Chelsea's clash with Tottenham. Palmer received a yellow card in the 71st minute following a clash with Mateus Fernandes, with questions raised over whether the incident warranted a red card.Then, in the 80th minute, Palmer was sent off following a late challenge involving Conor Gallagher.Should Palmer have seen red for the earlier incident? Did the referee miss a potential sending-off offence? And could Chelsea have been reduced to nine men? We break down both incidents and examine the decisions.🔵 RANGERS vs ST JOHNSTONE: VAR RED CARD DRAMA!St Johnstone's Kai Fotheringham was shown a red card following a VAR review after his studs collided with Rangers midfielder Nicolas Raskin's leg.Was the dismissal the correct decision? Did the referee make the right call after reviewing the incident, or was the punishment too harsh? We discuss the challenge and the role VAR played in the sending-off.🟠 DUNDEE UNITED'S DISALLOWED GOAL: DID VAR GET IT WRONG?Dundee United beat Aberdeen 3–2 at Tannadice, but Zac Sapsford's controversial goal being ruled out for offside sparked plenty of debate.Following a VAR review, teammate Daniel Bennie was judged to have interfered with play from an offside position. The decision drew criticism, with questions raised over whether the intervention was justified.Was this the correct application of the offside law? Did Bennie genuinely interfere with an opponent, or was this another example of VAR getting involved when it shouldn't?We examine the decision and discuss why this controversial offside call has left so many fans confused.🌧️ WATERLOGGED PITCHES, POSTPONEMENTS & FOOTBALL COMEDY!It's been a nightmare for football across the country, with numerous matches postponed because of waterlogged pitches.But while some games were called off, others went ahead in conditions that made football almost impossible! With the ball landing in puddles and struggling to travel any distance, some matches provided extraordinary scenes.And who benefited from the boggy conditions? Partick Thistle, who thrashed Stenhousemuir 3–0 on a waterlogged Firhill pitch!Should these matches have been played, or should player safety and the quality of the game come first?💬 JOIN THE DEBATE!We want to hear YOUR verdict! Drop your opinions in the comments below!👍 Make sure to LIKE the video, SUBSCRIBE to So Near, Yet So VAR, and hit the notification bell so you never miss an episode!👉 Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR#VAR #Football #Referee #PremierLeague #IpswichTown #NottinghamForest #Chelsea #Tottenham #RangersFC #DundeeUnited #ScottishFootball #RedCard #FootballControversy #VARControversy #SoNearYetSoVAR

  • October 19 · 44 min

    Championship Needs VAR' | Morgan Rogers Dodges A Red | Handball Debate Rages on #VAR #epl #spfl

    On this weeks episode of So Near Yet So VAR, we dive straight into the the weekend's helping of big talking points, controversial decisions and VAR interventions, as host Gavin Wallace is joined by former FIFA officials Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden as they pass their verdict on it ALL.We look at Alexis Mac Allisters simulation against Brentford, which could easily have been an audition for Swan Lake, Morgan Rogers dodges a red card against Everton, Botman gets away with one at St James' Park, and following some refereeing clangers, should VAR be introduced into the English AND Scottish Championship. All this and much more, this week on So Near, Yet So VAR.Football explained by former professional referees.👉 Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR#Football #Referee #MarkClattenburg #BobbyMadden #FootballShorts #PremierLeague #FIFAReferee #Referees #Soccer #VAR

  • October 13 · 46 min

    FROM OLD TRAFFORD TO IBROX! 🔥 Bentancur's Red, Rangers' 'Handball' & Controversial Penalties #VAR

    Get the expert takes on all of this weekend's big football decisions, both north and south of the border on our first Youtube LIVE show. This week, ex-FIFA-approved referees Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden discuss: •⁠ ⁠Should Liverpool's Gravenberch have seen RED? •⁠ ⁠Everton opener against Hull, disallowed •⁠ ⁠Anan Khalaili offers a helping hand as Crystal Palace get away with one against Notts Forest •⁠ ⁠Fireworks at Old Trafford between Luke Shaw and Rodrigo Bentancur •⁠ ⁠Pascal Struijk sent for an early shower at the Stadium of Light as Brighton go down to 10 men against Sunderland •⁠ ⁠Fan Question: Bobby and Mark discuss their journeys to becoming a category 1 referee •⁠ ⁠Did Kevin Kelsy handle the ball for Rangers' second against Kilmarnock? •⁠ ⁠Hibs Devaney picks up a red card against Dundee Utd, after just 6 minutes on the pitch. Right call? •⁠ ⁠St Mirren capitulate as they ship 2 penalties against Hearts •⁠ ⁠Was the ref right to award Dundee a penalty against Falkirk? •⁠ ⁠St Johnstone clinch 3 points with a penalty at Pittodrie •⁠ ⁠Nick Walsh flying the flag for Scottish referees in the Champions League •⁠ ⁠Lazy refereeing at West Ham V QPR? •⁠ ⁠VAR in the Championship?

  • September 20 · 45 min

    Ep 5: Rice and Fernandez escaping punishment | Offsides galore

    Welcome to episode 5 of So Near Yet So VAR. Host Gavin Wallace is joined by former FIFA officials Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden to discuss the weekend's drama. In this episode, the team discuss: - Declan Rice missing red? - Old Firm Fernandez a lucky man? - Hearts and the Harry McGuire law Covering all the big talking points from North and South of the border over the weekend. Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR

  • September 13 · 46 min

    Ep 4: Haaland's Offside Shocker, Foden Sees RED, Old Firm Review and MORE!

    Welcome to episode 4 of So Near Yet So VAR. Host Gavin Wallace is joined by former FIFA officials Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden to discuss the weekend's drama. In this episode, the team discuss: - Manchester derby madness - Old Firm cup clash review - Arsenal penalty complaint - Villa want red Covering all the big talking points from North and South of the border over the weekend. Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR

  • S1 · E3
    September 6 · 48 min

    Ep 3: Quit playing games with my VAR

    Welcome to episode 3 of So Near Yet So VAR. Host Gavin Wallace is joined by former FIFA officials Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden to discuss the weekends drama.On this episode, the team discuss: Hand of Nico: Forrest goal chopped off Liverpool penalty claim: Gakpo goes down, in or out? Celtic’s offence at offside in Paisley: Not once, but twice Mike Dean playing games: Bravado or insanity? Covering all the other big decisions from a big midweek in Scotland, and both North and South of the border over the weekend. Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR

  • August 31 · 51 min

    Ep 2: The VAR Bar for intervention remains high

    Welcome to episode 2 of So Near Yet So VAR. Host Gavin Wallace is joined by former FIFA officials Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden to discuss the weekend's drama.On this episode, the team discuss:* Harry’s helping hand: Manchester United take the lead against Ipswich with a controversial decision.* Allison’s Anfield analysis: Should Forest have received a crucial penalty against Liverpool?* Aberdeen v Rangers: It wouldn’t be the same without some Pittodrie pantomime.The refereeing drama continues, and we will return next Sunday evening. Please remember to subscribe, like, share and comment. Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR

  • August 24 · 59 min

    Ep 1: England’s Premier League returns with a debut Villain, while north of the border, a Dundee derby mistaken identity debate ⚽️

    On the debut episode of So Near ,Yet So VAR, we dive straight into the opening weekend's biggest talking points as host Gavin Wallace is joined by former FIFA officials Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden We dissect João Gomes’ disastrous, red-carded Aston Villa debut against Brighton, Man City's late winner allowed at the Etihad after an offside flag scare, and Dominik Szoboszlai's ice-cool 99th-minute penalty rescue for Liverpool at St. James' Park. Plus, in Scotland we unpack a baffling case of mistaken identity in the Dundee derby. The refereeing drama is officially back and we will return every Sunday evening to review it for you. Please remember to subscribe, like, share and comment. 👉 Follow the show, find our socials, and watch video clips here: https://linktr.ee/SoNearYetSoVAR

  • S1 · E1
    August 4 · 14 min

    Season 1 Ep 1 - New beginning

    We are back! In episode 1 we review all the incidents from the opening weekend in Scottish football. With a weeks notice, some delivery challenges and selecting the wrong ration when publishing, we are now live! Feedback is welcome and share your opinions in the comments section, like follow and subscribe.

  • July 29 · 1 min

    Season 1 Trailer

    With the league football season fast approaching and making the decision to produce a podcast with six days to the big kick off, we have a trailer! As we await the mic and camera we quickly touch on what people can expect from So Near Yet So VAR. A fifteen minute review of all the controversial decisions every Monday morning, providing insight and clarity on those big talking points. Have a great season one and all!

Showing 1–12 of 12 episodes