
HAVERTZ DENIED A CLEAR PENALTY?! #footballpodcast #sonearyetsovar #refereecontroversy #vardebate
🚨 PENRICE WINS A CONTROVERSIAL PENALTY! HAVERTZ DENIED ONE?! | So Near, Yet So VARFormer FIFA-accredited referees Mark Clattenburg and Bobby Madden are back to analyse another weekend of controversial VAR decisions, penalty incidents, red cards and refereeing talking points from the English Premier League and Scottish Premiership.⚖️ THIS WEEK'S BIGGEST TALKING POINTS:🔵 ST MIRREN 0-2 RANGERS: JAMES PENRICE WINS A SOFT PENALTY?Rangers are awarded a controversial first-half penalty after James Penrice goes down under minimal contact from St Mirren's Samuel Ramos. Referee Nick Walsh points to the spot and VAR Greg Aitken allows the decision to stand. Was it a clear penalty, or did Penrice make the most of the contact? Bobby Madden and Mark Clattenburg give their verdicts.🔴 ARSENAL vs HULL: KAI HAVERTZ DENIED A CLEAR PENALTY?!The major talking point of the weekend! Hull defender Nobel Mendy pulls Kai Havertz's shirt inside the penalty area, but after a VAR review, referee Farai Hallam overturns the penalty decision and awards Hull a free-kick for offside. Was this a major misunderstanding of the offside law? Can a player be penalised for offside before committing an active offside offence? And did Arsenal get a penalty decision completely wrong? Arsenal eventually win 1-0 through Martin Ødegaard.⚪ LEEDS vs TOTTENHAM: SHOULD JAYDEN BOGLE HAVE SEEN RED?Jayden Bogle catches Mathys Tel around the Achilles with his studs, but VAR Tony Harrington backs the on-field decision. Tottenham are reportedly seeking answers over the incident. We also examine Mateus Fernandes' early handball appeal.🔵 SUNDERLAND vs CHELSEA: TWO CONTROVERSIAL PENALTY DECISIONSCole Palmer goes down after contact from Luke O'Nien, but no penalty is awarded, with VAR judging the contact to be outside the box. At the other end, Brian Brobbey wins a penalty against Levi Colwill. Were both decisions correct?🔵 EVERTON vs COVENTRY: TARKOWSKI HAIR-PULL CONTROVERSYJames Tarkowski appears to pull Caleb Yirenkyi's hair inside the penalty area, but Coventry are not awarded a penalty. Why did VAR stay out of it?🔴 BRIGHTON vs BRENTFORD: IGOR THIAGO SENT OFFMichael Oliver upgrades Thiago's yellow card to a straight red after VAR review for catching Andrés in the face. Was the dismissal justified?🍀 CELTIC vs KILMARNOCK: GOAL OVERTURNED BY VARKasper Høgh's goal is ruled out following a pitchside review for a foul by Mika Baur on Greg Kiltie. Was it a soft decision? We also look at Baur's disallowed goal for offside.🎙️ EXPERT ANALYSIS FROM MARK CLATTENBURG & BOBBY MADDENFrom controversial penalties and shirt pulls to offside interpretations, handballs and red cards, our former FIFA-accredited referees explain the Laws of the Game and give their expert verdicts.Timestamp:00:00:00 - 00:01:02 Intro00:01:02 - 00:06:32 Havertz Penalty Debate00:06:32 - 00:09:05 Fernandes Handball00:09:05 - 00:12:24 Bogle challenge on Tel00:12:24 - 00:17:08 James Tarkowski handful of hair00:17:08 - 00:19:34 Thiago sees RED00:19:34 - 00:22:19 Cole Palmer denied a pen00:22:19 - 00:27:22 Are English Refs relying TOO MUCH on VAR?00:27:22 - 00:33:22 Brobbey's controversial penalty00:33:22 - 00:34:57 Raith v Dunfermline: Pars miss out on a Penalty: Neil Lennon's reaction00:34:57 - 00:38:38 Best and worst stadiums to referee at00:38:38 - 00:40:32 Bobby's trip to Saudi00:40:32 - 00:46:42 Does Penrice con the ref?00:46:42 - 00:47:57 Høgh's disallowed goal00:47:57 - 00:49:28 Tshibola handball. Penalty to Celtic00:49:28 - 00:50:18 Outro💬 JOIN THE DEBATE!Was Kai Havertz robbed of a penalty? Did James Penrice win a soft spot-kick? Which refereeing decision was the biggest mistake of the weekend?Leave your verdict in the comments!👍 LIKE, SUBSCRIBE and turn on notifications for more expert VAR analysis, Premier League refereeing controversies and Scottish football decision reviews.So Near, Yet So VAR – the decisions, the debate and the expert verdict.