Movie Joust!

Jesse Nussman, Jason Evans, Josh Sewell

Movie Joust! is a movie podcast where critics with clashing tastes challenge hype, legacy, and consensus — forcing films to earn their reputation.

Each week, Atlanta film critics debate new releases, awards contenders, and cultural flashpoints in cinema, putting “prestige,” popularity, and critical buzz under pressure. From legacy filmmakers to divisive adaptations, Movie Joust! isn’t about polite agreement — it’s about sharp takes, real disagreement, and figuring out who movies are actually for.

If you’re tired of plot recaps and safe opinions, welcome to the fight.

Play

Open in

29 episodes
weekly
Avg 46 min
English

Episodes 29

Newest Oldest Longest

All20 Unplayed20 In progress0 Played0

Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.

October 24 · 51 min
'Clayface' Brings Horror to DC Universe | Plus, 'Wicker,' and 'A Talent for Murder'
In this episode of Movie Joust!, we dive into DC’s latest release, Clayface, exploring how director James Watkins transforms the iconic Gotham villain's origin story into a dark body-horror thriller. Plus, we review the quirky romantic fantasy Wicker and Anton Corbijn's literary mystery-thriller A Talent for Murder starring Helen Mirren.
October 18 · 1 hr 7 min
'You Can See Everything' is a Masterpiece | Plus, 'Musk' and 'Whalefall'
Is Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s A24 documentary 'You Can See Everything' an instant non-fiction masterpiece? On this episode of Movie Joust!, we dive deep into the mind-bending Elizabeth Holmes doc that has everyone talking. Plus, we break down Alex Gibney's epic Elong Musk documentary, 'Musk', and Brian Duffield’s claustrophobic survival thriller 'Whalefall'! Which of these heavy hitters takes top honors, and which one gets thrown to the wolves?
October 13 · 54 min
'The Social Reckoning' Takes on Facebook | Plus, 'Tenzing' & 'Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother'
This week, the guys give their thoughts on "The Social Reckoning," Aaron Sorkin's spiritual sequel to the 2010 film "The Social Network." Then, they play catch-up with Apple's Everest-set biopic "Tenzing," and "Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother," a unique new thriller starring Mahershala Ali.
October 4 · 1 hr 1 min
'Digger' Review: Is Tom Cruise's Latest a Misunderstood Masterpiece or Epic Disaster? | Plus, 'Primetime' and 'Verity'
It's a jam-packed episode this week, as Jason, Jesse, and Josh joust over the merits of "Digger," Alejandro González Iñárritu's satirical comedy starring Tom Cruise. Then, the guys catch up with the Robert Pattinson starring "Primetime," about the series "To Catch a Predator," and Jason gives his reactions to the latest Colleen Hoover adaptation, "Verity".
September 20 · 35 min
'Resident Evil' Rocks! | Plus, Ethan Hawke and Russell Crowe in 'The Weight'
This week, the guys enthusiastically talk about Zach Cregger's adaptation of the beloved horror game "Resident Evil," then they break down another new release, this time featuring Ethan Hawke and Russell Crowe. Hear why this adventure film calls to mind classics such as "Sorcerer" and "Treasure of the Sierra Madre."
September 14 · 47 min
September Movie Rundown | Practical Magic 2, Hope, and The Runner
Jesse and Josh run through multiple movies currently out. First, Nicole Kidman and Sandra Bullock reunite in "Practical Magic 2" then a South Korean monster movie with some real high highs and real low lows, and finally, the Gal Gadot Amazon thriller that is going viral for all the wrong reasons.
September 5 · 33 min
'Onslaught' Review & the Return of Mumblecore Favorites
Remember the Mumblecore movement of the early 2010s? This week, we're discussing new movies from two of the movement's notable filmmakers; Joe Swanberg and Adam Winguard. Plus, a discussion on if horror movies need to be "about something" or if the "elevated horror" trend has thrown off our expectations for genre entertainment.
August 28 · 39 min
End of Summer Hangover Movies | It Ends, Dog Stars, & More
We're at the final days of summer movie season. And that means it's a grab bag of choices, from the Gen-Z indie-horror flick "It Ends," to the post-apocalyptic world of "The Dog Stars," and even the Looney Tunes flick "Coyote vs. Acme."
August 22 · 39 min
'Tony' & 'The Rivals of Amziah King' | Two Late-Summer Character Dramas
This week we discuss A24's Tony, Matt Johnson's kinetic, unvarnished biographical snapshot of a 19-year-old Anthony Bourdain (Dominic Sessa) slinging seafood in 1975 Provincetown. In the other corner stands Andrew Patterson's gritty, Southern-gothic indie thriller The Rivals of Amziah King, starring Matthew McConaughey as a beekeeping, folk-rocking town anchor caught in a high-stakes local honey syndicate war.
August 15 · 39 min
'The End of Oak Street' vs. 'Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma' Review
From suburban dinosaur chaos in The End of Oak Street to classic slasher tropes and dark comedy in Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma, the team breaks down script execution, critical buzz, and box office potential. Tune in for our full review, clash of opinions, and final verdicts on whether these new releases earn their place or fall flat.
August 9 · 44 min
Dystopian Rom-Com vs. Eli Roth Horror: One Night Only & Ice Cream Man Review
On this episode of Movie Joust, we go head-to-head on two of the wildest August 2026 theatrical releases: Will Gluck’s high-concept romantic comedy One Night Only and Eli Roth’s twisted horror slasher Ice Cream Man.
August 1 · 46 min
Spider-Man: Brand New Day Review: MCU Saved or Overhyped?
In this episode of Movie Joust, we dive headfirst into Marvel's latest blockbuster, Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026)! We break down Tom Holland’s return as Peter Parker, Destin Daniel Cretton’s direction, and the introduction of Sadie Sink's Jean Grey. Tune in for our full spoiler review, character breakdowns, and final verdict!
July 27 · 56 min
Fall Movie Box Office Predictions!
In this episode, three seasoned film critics — Jason Evans, Jesse Nussman, and Josh Sewell — dive into the unpredictable world of September and October releases. You'll discover how Tom Cruise's choice of "Digger" could dominate the box office, why dinosaurs in "End of Oak Street" might surprise everyone, and which indie gem "The Rivals of Amziah King" could steal the critics' hearts despite a modest box office. We break down the scoring systems for audience favorites and critical acclaim, revealing the art and science behind what makes a movie legendary or forgettable.
July 16 · 48 min
Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey Review | IMAX Masterpiece or Overindulgent Epic
On this week's episode of Movie Joust!, Atlanta film critics Jason, Jesse, and Josh step into the arena to debate Nolan's massive, $250 million adaptation of Homer's ancient Greek epic. Shot entirely on IMAX 70mm film cameras, this ambitious feature stars Matt Damon as Odysseus, Anne Hathaway as Penelope, and Tom Holland as Telemachus, alongside a star-studded ensemble including Robert Pattinson, Zendaya, Charlize Theron, and Lupita Nyong'o. We break down everything from Nolan's stunning visual set-pieces—including the nightmarish encounter with Polyphemus the Cyclops and Circe's demented magic—to his modern, non-linear exploration of war-induced PTSD and survivor's guilt. Does Matt Damon capture the complicated, wily nature of Odysseus? Does the screenplay's casual dialogue match the grand scale of Hoyte van Hoytema’s breathtaking cinematography? Or does the three-hour runtime struggle to carry the weight of its own ambition?
July 10 · 38 min
Island Gods, Awkward Dinners, and the Ultimate Jon Hamm Pass
This week on Movie Joust!, we are squaring off against a wildly diverse trio of new releases. First up, we set sail into controversial waters to review Disney's brand-new live-action reimagining of Moana. Does Thomas Kail’s beat-by-beat remake capture the magic of the reef, or does Dwayne Johnson's return as Maui feel like an unnecessary corporate cash grab? Then, we transition from the open ocean to the claustrophobic crucible of Olivia Wilde’s dark comedy, The Invite. We break down the cringe, the marital tension, and the extreme sexual FOMO that erupts when Seth Rogen and Olivia Wilde invite their eccentric upstairs neighbors (played by Edward Norton and Penelope Cruz) over for the dinner party from hell. Finally, we hit the chaotic streets of Hollywood with David Wain's absurd new comedy, Gail Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass. We track Zoey Deutch’s hilarious, Wizard of Oz-style odyssey to track down Jon Hamm and even the marital scales.
June 28 · 52 min
'Supergirl' thoughts | Plus, is 'Toy Story' the best movie franchise?
This week, Jason and Josh give their thoughts on 'Supergirl' and whether it signals the end of the superhero movie era. Then, Jesse joins to talk about 'Toy Story 5' and determine if Pixar's flagship series is the most consistently good movie franchise.
June 22 · 1 hr 12 min
Steven Spielberg Movies Ranked | From 'Jaws' to 'Disclosure Day'
With "Disclosure Day" out in theaters, we're ranking all 35 movies directed by Steven Spielberg and placing them into our own tier list.
June 14 · 46 min
'Disclosure Day' Review | Thoughts on Steven Spielberg's Alien Picture
Jesse and Josh both break down Steven Spielberg's new UFO movie starring Emily Blunt, Josh O'Conner, Colin Firth, and Colman Domingo. We break down which Spielberg classics it is closest to, and its uniquely optimistic ideas about life from other worlds. #DisclosureDay #MovieReview #MoviePodcast
May 25 · 38 min
'The Mandalorian & Grogu' Review | 'Obsession' Becomes Horror Phenomenon
On this week's episode, we review the latest 'Star Wars' entry and ponder why this franchise feels so stale now. Then, we share our excitement for one of the year's surprise hits, the horror movie "Obsession."
May 9 · 1 hr
'Star Wars' Movie Rankings
With a new 'Star Wars' movie right around the corner, Jason, Jesse, and Josh are looking back on the previous journeys to a galaxy far, far away.

Showing 1–20 of 29 episodes