Dr Cliff Harvey on Misinformation, Influencers and Nutrition Evidence
Save 20% on all Nuzest Products WORLDWIDE with the code MIKKIPEDIA at www.nuzest.co.nz, www.nuzest.com.au or www.nuzest.com Episode Summary Dr Cliff Harvey is back for another free-ranging catch-up, and as usual the conversation goes in plenty of directions. Cliff is a PhD-qualified researcher, naturopath and strength and conditioning coach who has been in clinical practice for almost 30 years, and he heads up the Holistic Performance Institute. He and Mikki start with flavoured water, chewing gum and why how we feel about a habit can matter more than the habit itself, then move through wearables, the limits of AI for health advice, and Cliff's work on systemic nickel allergy, including his own case with Crohn's disease. From there the thread is critical thinking: why carnivore content has such an outsized footprint online, the difference between misinformation and disinformation, what the evidence actually says about low-carb versus high-carb diets, and how to weigh epidemiology against RCTs. They also talk about the psychology of moderators versus abstainers, why personality labels can become limiting stories, fasting protocols marketed to women, and why a plausible mechanism is only the first step in showing that something makes a meaningful difference in real life. Key Topics Why it is often how we feel about a behaviour, rather than the behaviour itself, that bothers us — from Mikki's reliance on water flavour drops and her old 14-a-day gum habit, to Cliff relaxing about a teaspoon of sugar in his iced coffee Wearables and sleep tracking: some people get more stressed by their sleep data, yet it can still be a useful call to action; Mikki deliberately broke her step streak so she would obsess about it less Where AI helps (planning, brainstorming, business tasks) and where it falls short in coaching, because it lacks common sense and individual context — and why it takes expertise to know the next question to ask Systemic nickel allergy: why Cliff says a vegan diet can be medically contraindicated for some people with it, the higher rate of nickel allergy in people with inflammatory bowel disease, his estimate that it is more common than coeliac disease, and common sources of sensitisation such as jewellery, tattoo inks, medical implants and stainless steel Why carnivore content takes up so much space online relative to how few people follow the diet, and Cliff's case that the fibre evidence, both observational and from trials, consistently points to benefit Misinformation versus disinformation, and Cliff's view that leaving out inconvenient evidence counts as the latter Low carb versus high carb: some people do better on each, differences by insulin status or body composition are marginal, and in a calorie deficit everyone loses fat — so the best diet is the one you can follow, including abstention-based approaches for some people The strengths and limits of epidemiology and RCTs, why metabolic ward studies translate poorly to real life, and the "bookend effect" that makes low-carb diet scores look worse until diet quality is accounted for Setting energy and protein targets rather than carb and fat targets for most clients, and how tracking for long enough can make tracking unnecessary Moderators, abstainers and personality labels as tools rather than identities; the Buddhist "hungry ghost" analogy; and why mechanistic plausibility, fasting and autophagy need real-world evidence of a meaningful effect Chapters 00:00 Introduction 03:55 Flavoured water, gum and habits 08:44 Wearables, tracking and AI advice 16:12 Systemic nickel allergy and Crohn's 24:35 Carnivore, influencers and fibre 30:42 Misinformation and the carb debate 34:47 Epidemiology versus RCTs 38:50 Protein, fibre and flexible macros 41:55 Moderators, abstainers and personality labels 50:13 Fasting protocols and appeal to authority 56:14 Mechanisms, fasting and energy balance 1:01:12 Wrap-up and where to find Cliff Guest / Resources Dr Cliff Harvey Holistic Performance Institute: holisticperformance.institute Website: cliffharvey.com Instagram: @cliffdoggydog Cliff has a PhD, is a naturopath and a strength and conditioning coach, and has been in clinical practice for almost 30 years, working with professional, Olympic and Commonwealth athletes as well as people managing chronic health conditions. He heads up the Holistic Performance Institute, which offers certification and diploma programmes in health, nutrition, health coaching and performance. Research discussed Harvey CJD (2026). Improvement of cutaneous and gastrointestinal symptoms in Crohn's disease following a low-nickel diet: A case report and narrative review. Journal of Metabolic Health, 9(1), a127. Cliff's own published case report and review on systemic nickel allergy, which he refers to in the episode. The DIETFITS trial, which Cliff mentions in the context of low-carb versus low-fat diets and baseline insulin status. Cliff also refers to research on nickel allergy and inflammatory bowel disease, on fibre (observational studies, trials and fibre supplements), on overfeeding with carbohydrate versus fat, and on low-carb diet scores and diet quality. These were discussed in general terms, and no specific papers were named. People and books mentioned Dr Mindy Pelz, Fast Like a Girl — discussed critically as an example of a fasting protocol marketed to women that goes beyond the evidence Dr Jordan Feigenbaum (Barbell Medicine) — Cliff recommends him as a pragmatic, evidence-based voice and is reading Signal: What Testosterone Levels Are Telling You About Your Health, co-written with Dr Austin Baraki Dr Eric Helms — mentioned as another evidence-based voice worth following Dr Charles Brenner — previous Mikkipedia guest, discussed in relation to nicotinamide riboside, NAD and translating lab research to people Lauren Colenso-Semple — researcher Cliff recently spoke with about wearables and tracking Sarah Wilson, I Quit Sugar — the book Mikki credits with her light bulb moment about artificial sweeteners From Mikki Mondays to Mastery — Mikki's small-group coaching programme The 40 Over 40 dinner book, available at mikkiwilliden.com Instagram, Threads and X: @mikkiwilliden Facebook: Mikki Williden Nutrition Website: mikkiwilliden.com Curranz Supplement: Use code MIKKIPEDIA to get 20% off your first order - go to www.curranz.co.nz or www.curranz.co.uk to order yours NZ listeners - save 10% off Calocurb by using the code Mikkipedia10 at www.calocurb.co.nz Contact Mikki: https://mikkiwilliden.com/ https://www.facebook.com/mikkiwillidennutrition https://www.instagram.com/mikkiwilliden/ https://linktr.ee/mikkiwilliden
- Transcript
- Chapters