Skip to content
Sign in
Artwork for Midnight Mystery Archive
True CrimeSociety & CultureDocumentary

Midnight Mystery Archive

Kevin Hall | Archive Podcast Network

Midnight Mystery Archive explores unsolved cases, disappearances, conspiracies, and forgotten mysteries through research, storytelling, and clear analysis. Hosted by Kevin Hall, the show takes listeners deeper into the cases that shape our curiosity and haunt our history — always with respect for the victims and their families. Part of the Archive Podcast Network.

Play
Open in
  • 22 episodes
  • a few times a week
  • Avg 17 min
  • English

Support the show

Goes straight to the publisher. podnod takes nothing.

Episodes 22

NewestOldestLongest
All20Unplayed20In progress0Played0
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • S4 · E157
    Today · 34 min

    Judge Joseph Crater: The 1930 Disappearance of a New York Supreme Court Justice

    On the evening of August 6, 1930, New York Supreme Court Justice Joseph Force Crater finished dinner at a West 45th Street chop house, said goodbye to two companions, and walked out of the historical record. The police weren’t told for 28 days. The case stayed open for nearly 50 years. Tonight’s story follows the documented trail: Crater’s rise through Tammany Hall’s Cayuga Democratic Club, his appointment to the bench by Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt just four months earlier, and the hurried final days in which he destroyed papers, moved files, and cashed checks totaling $5,150. We look at the dinner at Billy Haas’s with a Schubert lawyer and a showgirl, and at how the familiar image of Crater stepping into a taxi rests on thinner evidence than the legend suggests. Then the aftermath: the month-long delay in reporting him missing, a grand jury that gathered roughly 2,000 pages of testimony and reached no conclusion, a flood of sightings, and the four envelopes Stella Crater found in a bureau drawer months later, including a handwritten note that can be read more than one way. Finally, the theories, graded by what actually supports them: a voluntary disappearance or suicide, a political killing tied to Tammany Hall and the judgeship scandals, a blackmail plot, a gangland connection, and a sealed 2005 letter naming a spot under the Coney Island boardwalk. Evidence first, speculation clearly labeled. Sources include Richard Tofel’s Vanishing Point, the New York Sun, the Saturday Evening Post, the Daily News, the Charley Project, and Lafayette College’s archive. The full source list is in the show notes. Subscribe for new episodes of Midnight Mystery Archive. Part of the Archive Podcast Network. Find us: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | midnightmysteryarchive.com #JudgeCrater #JosephCrater #ColdCase #UnsolvedMysteries #TammanyHall #1930s #NewYorkHistory #MissingPerson #HistoricalMystery #TrueCrimePodcast #MidnightMysteryArchive Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E156
    October 23 · 34 min

    Dorothy Arnold: The Wave on Fifth Avenue (1910)

    On December 12, 1910, Dorothy Arnold, a 25-year-old Bryn Mawr graduate and aspiring writer from a prominent Manhattan family, left home to go shopping. A little before two that afternoon, she spoke with a friend outside Brentano’s bookstore on Fifth Avenue. The friend waved goodbye from the corner. No one has been documented seeing Dorothy Arnold since. Her family waited roughly six weeks to go public. The search that followed spanned Pinkerton agents, transatlantic cables, a confrontation in Florence, and the dragging of Central Park ponds. Over the decades, five explanations have survived, and a handful of false leads, hoaxes and claims have come and gone. This episode walks through the documented record, presents the evidence for and against each theory without ranking them, and flags the places where historical sources disagree. Sources: Allen Churchill, “The Girl Who Never Came Back,” American Heritage (1960); Rosemary Counter, National Geographic (2024); The Charley Project; period newspaper reporting. The Charley Project maintains the public case file for Dorothy Arnold and thousands of other missing persons: charleyproject.org Midnight Mystery Archive is a research-driven show with an evidence-first, no-speculation standard. New episodes bi-weekly. Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E155
    September 11 · 15 min

    The Final Episode of MMA. 10,000 People in a Family Tree. One Name Left. | Kerryn Tate Pt. 2

    This is the final episode of the Midnight Mystery Archive. In Part 1, we covered who Kerryn Tate was and what happened on December 29, 1979: a 22-year-old woman hitchhiking southeast of Perth, a deliberately set fire, a body found in bushland near the Canning Dam catchment. 45 years of the case staying open. And the biological evidence recovered at the scene in 1979 that police kept, year after year, waiting for science to catch up. This is Part 2. The science caught up. In 2023, Western Australia Police handed that biological evidence to their investigative genetic genealogy team — a unit WA Police has described as leading the world in this methodology. The team uploaded the DNA to a public genealogy database, the same kind people use to find their cousins and trace their ancestry. The database returned genetic matches: not to the offender, but to their relatives. From those relatives, the team built a family tree. Ten thousand people. Constructed from birth certificates, death records, census data, genealogical archives, and genetic connections. Every branch narrowed the pool. At the end of that tree was one name. Terrence John Fisher. Fisher had died in 2000 at the age of 50, of natural causes, while living with his father in Manning, Perth. He had never been charged. His name had never appeared in the original 1979 investigation. He had lived his life — working as a carpenter with the WA Public Works Department, sailing at the Fremantle Sailing Club, frequenting pubs in Carlisle and Victoria Park and Manning — and had died without ever facing a single consequence. When WA Police named Fisher publicly in March 2025, they also said this: if Fisher were alive, he would be a person of interest in the deaths of two other Western Australian women — Barbara Western, murdered in 1986, and Carrie Turner, murdered in 1991. That is not an accusation. It is a statement of investigative significance. Police do not name dead men as persons of interest in other murders without a reason. The reason is not publicly detailed. What it means is that investigators looked at those three deaths and saw something worth pursuing. Terrence John Fisher cannot be arrested. He cannot be tried. He cannot be convicted. Whatever he did on December 29, 1979, he died having never faced it. Kerryn Tate's sister Anne-Marie Tate said publicly: "I strongly urge anyone who's had even a slight suspicion about Terrence Fisher to please come forward to police." She is still asking. The family is still building the picture of who he was. So is WA Police. And the investigative genealogy team that identified him is still working. Kerryn Tate was 22 years old. She would be 68 today. This case, and this show, are for her. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E154
    September 4 · 18 min

    Perth 1979. A Young Woman Accepted a Lift. 45 Years Later, They Named Who Did It. | MMA

    This is the final series of the Midnight Mystery Archive — the last two-parter before the podcast goes on hiatus. It ends in Australia, one of MMA's largest listener bases, with a case that captures something essential about why this show existed: what happens when a young woman's life is cut short, and what forensic science can now do that nobody could have imagined when the crime occurred. Kerryn Tate was 22 years old when she was murdered in bushland southeast of Perth, Western Australia, on December 29, 1979. Forty-five years later, in March 2025, Western Australia Police named their prime suspect. He died in 2000. He will never stand trial. But his name is now on the record. This is Part 1: who Kerryn was, what happened on December 29, 1979, and how a case with almost no leads in 1979 eventually had a name to put to it. Kerryn was born in New South Wales and had been living in Western Australia for about a year. She worked in the arts. She was warm, social, well-connected — the kind of person whose presence in a room you noticed. She also hitchhiked. In 1979 Perth, this was not reckless. It was mainstream. Young Australians hitchhiked to the beach, between suburbs, between cities. It was an ordinary mode of transport. Kerryn was so accustomed to it that she carried a black motorcycle helmet specifically so she could accept lifts from motorbikes. That helmet is evidence of a routine, not a risk. On the night of December 28th, Kerryn attended a dance at the North Cottesloe Surf Life Saving Club. She stayed with friends in Swanbourne. The following morning, December 29th, a friend drove her to her house-sitting address in Mount Lawley at approximately 11 AM. That is the last confirmed sighting of Kerryn Tate alive. She was heading to Karragullen, approximately 40 kilometers southeast of Perth, to house-sit for other friends. She presumably hitchhiked. The next morning, December 30th, forestry workers found her body in bushland near the Canning Dam catchment. She was slumped over a smoldering tree stump. A fire had been deliberately set around the scene — calculated, not panic. A bloodstained piece of wood was recovered nearby. Kerryn had been beaten to death. Her jewelry was gone: the watch, the earrings, the bangle, the pendant, the rings that the Christmas Day family had noticed just four days earlier. In 1979, without CCTV, without DNA, without any digital record of vehicle movements, identifying a stranger who gave a hitchhiker a lift on a rural road was essentially impossible. The case went cold. But it never closed. Police kept the biological material from the 1979 scene. In 2023, that evidence went to Western Australia Police's investigative genetic genealogy team. What they found is the story of Part 2. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E153
    August 28 · 21 min

    They Thought They Were Close. The 2023 Breakthrough Sent Them Back to Square One. | Deely Pt. 2

    For 23 years, investigators and the public assumed the dark figure captured walking behind Trevor Deely on Haddington Road — 34 seconds after Trevor passed the camera — was the same man who had waited outside his office for 34 minutes in the rain. In December 2023, that assumption was definitively disproved. Enhanced CCTV analysis, using the same UK-based company that had processed the footage in 2016, finally confirmed that the Haddington Road figure was a different person entirely — someone who had given a statement to the Garda in the original 2000 investigation. The footage had been too poor to confirm his identity at the time. The 2023 enhancement resolved it. He wasn't following Trevor. There was nothing sinister about his movements. Trevor's brother Mark described it as a "bittersweet moment" — and said it put investigators "nearly straight back to square one." The man in black who spoke to Trevor at the back gate of his office at 3:35 AM remains unidentified. That person — whoever they are — is still the central unresolved thread in this case. The Garda believes he may hold information critical to understanding what happened to Trevor. He may not know that. They are asking him to come forward. Part 2 also covers the Garda's working theory: two separate informants, in 2017 and 2019, told investigators that Trevor was accidentally shot by a known Dublin criminal and that his body was concealed in the Chapelizod area, roughly five and a half miles from where he was last seen. In August 2017, Garda sealed off a three-acre site in Chapelizod and searched for six weeks. They found a gun and a quantity of drugs. Neither was connected to Trevor. The search ended in September 2017 without finding him. Twenty-six years later, Trevor Deely has never been found. The man in black has never been identified. And the case remains open. This episode also covers the lasting impact of Trevor's disappearance on how Ireland handles missing persons — the Garda National Missing Persons Unit, CCTV preservation protocols, and Ireland's national Missing Persons Day — changes driven in large part by the failures exposed in those first four days of Trevor's investigation. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E152
    August 24 · 5 min

    Midnight Mystery Archive Is Going on Hiatus. Here's Why — and What's Still Coming. | MMA

    An important update for every Midnight Mystery Archive listener. Kevin announced on social media Thursday, August 20th that MMA is going on extended hiatus. This episode is his direct message to the listeners — what happened, why, and what's still coming before the feed goes quiet. A major professional opportunity that Kevin has been working toward for years has arrived, and producing MMA at the level it deserves — 12 to 15 hours a week, every week — is not compatible with what comes next. The decision was not easy. But it was the only honest one. Before the hiatus begins: Trevor Deely Part 1 drops today. Part 2 drops next Friday. After that, a two-part Australian series. When that Part 2 lands, the hiatus officially begins. What MMA became in 16 months: 150 episodes. Over 100,000 downloads and YouTube streams combined. A goal of 5,000 downloads in the first year that was essentially doubled. Cases that deserved to be told, told the way Kevin wanted to tell them — thoroughly, accurately, and with the missing person at the center of every episode. The feed stays active. Kevin stays active on social media. And he holds out hope that when things settle, there's a path back. Thank you to every listener who shared an episode, left a review, sent a tip, or just showed up every Friday. It meant everything. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E151
    August 21 · 24 min

    The Last Image of Trevor Deely Was at 4:14 AM. He Was Nine Minutes From Home. | MMA | Part 1

    He was nine minutes from home. A man in dark clothing had been standing outside his office for 34 minutes before he got there. That was December 8, 2000. Trevor Deely has never been found. Trevor Deely was 22 years old, working at the Bank of Ireland Asset Management office in Dublin. On the night of December 7, 2000, he attended his office Christmas party — drinks on Harcourt Street, dinner at the Hilton, on to a nightclub on Lower Leeson Street. Two things made the walk home that night different from any other night: it was a Thursday, not a Friday, so the streets were quieter than usual, and Dublin's taxi drivers were on strike. Everyone who would normally have flagged a cab was walking. Trevor was walking. At 3:35 AM, he stopped at the rear entrance of his office on Wilton Terrace to collect an umbrella. CCTV footage, digitally enhanced years later, shows a man dressed entirely in black had been standing outside that entrance since 3:00 AM — 34 minutes in the rain before Trevor arrived. The man approached Trevor at the gate. They spoke briefly. Trevor went inside alone, came out alone, and walked toward home. At 4:14:21 AM, a CCTV camera at the AIB ATM on the corner of Haddington Road and Baggot Street Bridge captured him walking past — umbrella in hand, slightly unsteady, nine minutes from his flat in Ballsbridge. Thirty-four seconds later, the same camera captured a dark figure walking in the same direction. That is the last confirmed record of Trevor Deely. The man who waited outside his office for 34 minutes has never been identified. Twenty-six years of public appeals, a formal reopening of the investigation, and a 2023 development that turned out to be a dead end. The man in black remains the central unresolved thread in one of Ireland's most enduring missing persons cases. Part 2 covers what the investigation found — and what it didn't. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E150
    August 17 · 9 min

    Trevor Deely Part 1 This Friday. Louisa Dunne Is Solved. And We're Not Done With Amy Bradley. | MMA Mini

    Trevor Deely Part 1 drops this Friday. The Louisa Dunne two-parter is wrapped. And the Amy Bradley work is far from over. A quick Monday update on where we are and what's coming. Louisa Dunne. A 1967 murder in Bristol that went cold almost immediately and stayed cold for 56 years. Three things made the eventual conviction possible: officers in 1967 who processed that crime scene at a standard well above what the era required; the people who stored that evidence correctly for more than five decades; and the MCRT in 2023 who had the will to go back and ask whether the evidence had ever been tested. The answer was no. Louisa's blue skirt yielded a usable DNA sample that linked directly to Ryland Headley — who was 92 years old when he was sentenced to life in prison. Othram Labs and their advanced DNA technology are at the forefront of making cases like this possible, and Kevin reposts from their feed regularly on X. Trevor Deely. Part 1 this Friday. A case that is now a quarter century old and one of the most well-known disappearances in Ireland. Kevin won't spoil it — but it's a two-parter filled with mystery, intrigue, and questions that have gone unanswered for 25 years. Amy Bradley. Two Wednesdays ago, Kevin did a high-level review of James Renner's book on Amy's case and took direct aim at Renner's central theories. Last Wednesday, Stacie — Amy's best friend and the last person to see her in Richmond before the cruise — spoke publicly for the first time in 28 years. Stacie confirmed: Amy was looking forward to the trip. She was a little nervous about the plane ride and the water. She was genuinely happy to be going and to be spending that time with her family. That's not the end of it. Someone else has been reading Renner's book — closely, with sticky notes, going point by point through every claim she knows to be factually incorrect. She reached out. She has Kevin's platform whenever she needs it — one episode, three episodes, four episodes, whatever it takes. More to come on Amy Bradley. One last thing: if you want Kevin to be able to produce more series at the depth of Amy Bradley, there are a few things that help. A rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify takes 30 seconds. A subscribe on YouTube costs nothing. And if you want to go further — Patreon is at patreon.com/midnightmysteryarchive. Entry tier is $5 a month. That's it. Early access to episodes, and Kevin is working on additional patron exclusives. Echo 1953 — his debut novel, The Hollis Files Book 1 — is also on Amazon now: Kindle, Kindle Unlimited (free if you're a member), and paperback. Trevor Deely. Part 1. This Friday. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E148
    August 14 · 23 min

    How a Blue Skirt Preserved for 57 Years Convicted a Killer at 92. | Louisa Dunne Part 2

    Part 1 covered the night of June 28th, 1967: Louisa Dunne, 75 years old, murdered in her home in Easton, Bristol. Part 2 covers how they finally found him. It started with a question asked in 2023 by the Avon and Somerset Police Major Crime Review Team (MCRT): for every unsolved murder in their records, one by one are there forensic opportunities we have not pursued? For Louisa's case, the answer was yes. The blue skirt she was wearing when she was attacked had been tagged, bagged, and stored in the evidence inventory since 1967. It had never been submitted for DNA analysis, because DNA analysis didn't exist in 1967 — and no subsequent review had prioritized it. Three decisions over 56 years made the conviction possible. Someone in 1967 logged the skirt as evidence. Someone in the intervening decades maintained that storage rather than discarding it. And in 2023, someone asked whether it had ever been tested. Each decision was made without knowing the others would follow. Together, they built something those investigators never got to see finished. What the 2023 review found: two pieces of physical evidence had survived from the original crime scene. The palm print left on Louisa's rear window, the one that was the basis for the 19,000-man palm-printing exercise in 1967, was submitted to four independent fingerprint experts. All four reached the same conclusion: Ryland Headley. Unanimous. The semen recovered from Louisa's blue skirt was submitted for DNA analysis for the first time. The result was a full DNA profile that matched to Headley's DNA, which was already on the national database from an unrelated arrest. The match was one billion to one. There are eight billion people on Earth. If you tested every single one of them, you'd expect to find one match. Headley was that match. In November 2024, officers drove to Ipswich and knocked on the door of a house on Clarence Road. Ryland Headley was 92 years old. He was 34 when he killed Louisa. He had raped two more women in the decade that followed, served time, been released, and then lived in Ipswich for decades, presumably believing that after 57 years, it must be over. It was not over. He denied both offenses. The trial ran two weeks at Bristol Crown Court. The jury deliberated for nine hours and fifty-three minutes. They came back unanimous on rape and ten-to-two on murder. On July 1st, 2025, he was sentenced under the law as it stood in 1967, a foundational protection in English law that prevents retroactive punishment, to life imprisonment with a minimum of 20 years. He is 92. He cannot be considered for parole until he is 112. The judge was unambiguous: "You will die in prison." The judge also said: "You broke into her home, you sexually assaulted her, and in doing so, you caused her death. You may not have intended to kill, but you planned to rape her, and you brutally attacked her. When you did so, you met her screams and struggles with a force sufficient to kill." This conviction is now officially recognized as the oldest solved case in British criminal history. And it raises a direct question: how many others are waiting? The UK has hundreds of unsolved murders from the 1960s and 70s where evidence was collected and preserved but never submitted for DNA analysis. The national DNA database established in 1995 continues to grow with every new arrest. Cases like Louisa's, where a database match was simply waiting for the evidence submission, are going to happen again. Kevin closes with Louisa's granddaughter Mary, who gave a victim impact statement at trial. She said: "It has turned my life upside down. I feel sad and very tired, which has affected the relationships that I have with those closest to me. I didn't expect to deal with something of such emotional significance at this stage of my life." She was born after her grandmother was murdered. She grew up knowing Louisa only as an absence, a story, a case file that never closed. Then in 2024, the phone rang. The verdict doesn't give back 57 years. It gives something different: the knowledge that someone was held accountable, that the evidence was held in a blue skirt in a storage locker, and that someone eventually looked. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E149
    August 12 · 40 min

    Amy Bradley's Best Friend Saw Her the Night Before. She Speaks After Reading the Book. | MMA Special

    She was the last friend to see Amy Bradley in Richmond — the night before the cruise. She's here to talk about the book. Stacie was Amy Bradley's best friend. On the night before she left for the cruise, Amy asked her to come over. They sat in Amy's apartment, talked, and made plans for when Amy got back. The "angst" Kevin has described in prior episodes — the nervousness Amy's family spoke about before the trip — was about flying and being on water for the first time. Not about going with her family. Not about being forced anywhere. Stacie was there. She knows. Stacie rarely speaks publicly, but she reached out to Kevin because she felt she had to — because she watched the James Renner book come out and couldn't stay quiet. Here is what Stacie says about Renner's book: the research was done via ChatGPT, Reddit, and WebSleuths. There were no real interviews with people who actually knew Amy before the cruise — the people who knew who she was, what she liked, how she moved through the world, and where her life was at the time. More than half the book, by Stacie's account, is Renner writing about himself. He titled it "How I Found Myself While Searching for Amy Lynn Bradley." Stacie has thoughts about that title. On Amy's sexuality and identity: Amy didn't like labels. Stacie's exact words — "don't ever call her a lesbian." She was Amy. She liked who she liked. The Bradley family knew. Ron and Iva knew. Brad knew. The family didn't just accept it, they loved her like always. Ron and Iva came to karaoke nights. Stacie calls Iva "mom." Ron and Iva are, in her words, "disgustingly so much in love." They are not the family the book implies they are. On the specific claims in Renner's book: Stacie calls out the bungee jumping story and the James River swimming story as false. She addresses Yellow — the cruise crew member last seen with Amy who continues to lie about being in his room at 1AM despite his keycard data saying otherwise. Renner called Yellow credible anyway. Ron and Iva Bradley are well into their 70s. They exhausted their life savings searching for Amy. Both of them still go to work. They have never stopped. Stacie has letters from Amy. She has the original Richmond Times-Dispatch article from when Amy went missing. She has been carrying this for 28 years. She is here because Amy deserves people who actually knew her to speak for her. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E147
    August 10 · 9 min

    A 1967 Murder Solved by DNA in 2025. Louisa Dunne Is a Preview of What's Coming. | MMA Mini

    A murder from 1967. A 92-year-old man convicted in 2025. And DNA evidence recovered from a skirt that sat in storage for 57 years. Louisa Dunne's case isn't just a remarkable true crime story — Kevin thinks it's a preview of what's about to happen to dozens of cases that everyone has quietly accepted will never be solved. First, some follow-up on the James Renner special from last Wednesday. Kevin clarifies why he felt the need to address Renner's Amy Bradley book publicly: Renner has a documented history of sensationalizing cases, alienating families who don't cooperate — as he did with the Maura Murray family — and prioritizing his own narrative over the known facts. Having just completed an extensive series on Amy's case with access to her family, friends, eyewitnesses, and the former U.S. assistant attorney who convened the grand jury, Kevin felt it was necessary to push back on claims in the book that contradict the established record. He wishes Renner well and genuinely hopes he uses his real writing talent to do better by the victims and families he covers. On Louisa Dunne: Part 2 drops this Friday. What Kevin finds most significant about her case is not just the conviction — it's how it happened. Forensic genetic genealogy, the same technology pioneered by labs like Othram Labs, allowed investigators to extract a usable DNA profile from physical evidence that had been in storage since 1967 and cross-reference it against modern databases. A 92-year-old man who murdered a 75-year-old woman in Bristol, England and went on to commit further offenses — serving only seven years — was finally identified and convicted. Kevin believes cases like this are going to become a pattern, not an exception. If you're not already following Othram Labs on Facebook and X, he recommends it — they announce new case resolutions regularly. On the fall series: the planned Henry Lee Lucas false confession series has been set aside. Kevin found the source material thinner than expected and doesn't want to stretch it into a full series without enough substance. The fall is now open, and he's asking listeners for input. If you have an idea for a deep-dive series — similar in scope to the Amy Bradley series, six to twelve episodes of strong, well-documented material — send it to midnightmysteryarchive@gmail.com, the Facebook group, or X. Coming up: Louisa Dunne Part 2 this Friday, then the podcast heads to Ireland for the case of Trevor Deely — a well-known Irish case from the early 21st century. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E145
    August 7 · 19 min

    She Was Murdered in 1967. The Man Who Did It Was 92 When He Was Finally Convicted. | Louisa Dunne | Part 1

    Something different for the Midnight Mystery Archive: this case is solved. That's not how these episodes usually start. But the fact that it was solved is not the end of the story — it's why the story matters. Louisa Dunne was murdered in Bristol, England on June 28th, 1967. She was 75 years old. In November 2024, 57 years later, a 92-year-old man named Ryland Headley was arrested at his home in Ipswich. In June 2025, he was convicted of her murder and rape. In July 2025, he was sentenced to life in prison with a minimum of 20 years. He will die there. Part 1 is about Louisa and about what happened. Part 2 is about how they finally found him. Louisa was born Louisa Jane Jarrett in 1892. She married Edwin Parker, a Bristol city councillor, and was on track to become the mayoress of one of England's major cities. They had two daughters, Iris and Edna. Edwin died in 1945. She remarried a man named John Dunne in 1952; he died in 1961. By 1967, Louisa had been a widow for six years. Her daughters were estranged. Her world had contracted to 58 Britannia Street in Easton, East Bristol — a tight terraced row where neighbors noticed everything, where raised voices carried between walls, and where Louisa was known as the woman who was always at her front door, always ready to talk. Kevin spends time with who Louisa actually was before getting into the crime. She had been involved in the birth of the labor movement in Bristol. She was politically engaged, publicly visible, connected to the civic machinery of her city. By 1967, she was an elderly widow living alone on a quiet street. That trajectory — from political participant to isolated elderly woman — is the sharpest context for understanding why Ryland Headley selected her. On the night of June 27th — 28th, 1967, Headley, who was 34 years old and also living in Bristol at the time, forced open the rear window of Louisa's terraced house. He raped her. When she screamed and struggled — and she did, that's in the record — he pressed a hand over her mouth and applied pressure to her throat. She was 75 years old, alone, in her own home, and she still fought back. He killed her. He also robbed her. The judge at his 2025 sentencing was explicit: this was premeditated. The murder was the consequence of her resistance. Bristol Constabulary launched a massive investigation by 1967 standards: 2,000 statements, 8,000 house-to-house inquiries, and palm prints taken from 19,000 men and boys in the surrounding area — each one physically compared by hand against a palm print found on Louisa's rear window. There was no national fingerprint database in England in 1967. No computerized cross-referencing. The net was as large as the technology of the era could make it. Ryland Headley lived just outside the boundary of the house-to-house inquiries. He was not among the 19,000. The case went cold. He did not stop with Louisa. In the late 1970s, Headley was living in Ipswich. He broke into the homes of two elderly women and raped them — the same target profile, the same method of entry, the same pattern of violence. He was convicted, originally sentenced to life, but the sentence was reduced to seven years on appeal. He served it and was released. He lived in Ipswich for decades more. Two pieces of physical evidence from 1967 were preserved in storage: the palm print from the rear window, and semen found on the blue skirt Louisa was wearing when she was attacked. The tools to connect them to a suspect simply didn't exist yet. Part 2 covers what a 2023 cold case review team found in that blue skirt, what a billion-to-one DNA match looks like as evidence, and what happened when investigators finally knocked on Ryland Headley's door in November 2024. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Out now! Head on over to Amazon now and order! THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E146
    August 5 · 20 min

    I Read James Renner's Amy Bradley Book. Here's What He Got Wrong. | MMA Special

    James Renner's Amy Bradley book is out. Kevin has read it. And there are things that need to be addressed. Kevin spent months on the Amy Bradley series — working directly with her family, friends, eyewitnesses, and the former U.S. assistant attorney who convened a grand jury and got eyewitness statements under oath. He approached this book with that context in hand. This special episode isn't about Renner personally. It's about the evidence. Kevin walks through the book's key claims — the 4:30 AM timeline, the wind tunnel theory, the overemphasis on Kat and Molly, Yellow's credibility despite keycard data contradicting his stated timeline, and the suicide angle — and addresses each one against what the known, documented record actually shows. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable. Kevin doesn't dispute that. But David Carmichael, Judy Maurer, Crystal, Lori, Elizabeth Lewis, and the other witnesses in this case have maintained consistent accounts across nearly 30 years. Former U.S. Assistant Attorney Greg Nivela called each of them credible when he convened the grand jury. That distinction matters. Kevin also gives Renner credit where it's due: he's a good writer, and he was genuinely respectful toward the Bradley family through much of the book. But good writing in service of a predetermined narrative is not the same as good investigation. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Out now! Head on over to Amazon now and order! THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E144
    August 3 · 7 min

    "I Believe the OPP Know Who Killed Barbara Chapman." Plus: Louisa Dunn Is Next. | Mini

    Kevin wraps up the Barbara Chapman two-part series — and makes his first declarative statement of the international summer series. He's been careful throughout both Barbara Chapman episodes not to speculate. No wild claims, no overreach. That's been his policy since day one. But in this mini, he breaks from that stance and says it directly: he believes the Ontario Provincial Police know who killed Barbara Chapman, and he believes the November 2024 Northern Ontario witness appeal was a geographically targeted ask designed to compel information from someone who either is the perpetrator or is close to the perpetrator. He could be wrong. He says that plainly. But the specificity of that appeal — hundreds of kilometers from where Barbara was murdered in 1984 — tells him the OPP have something and are working toward a close. Now: the summer series heads to the UK. The next case is the 1967 murder of Louisa Dunn — and it's a different kind of episode for the Midnight Mystery Archive. Kevin spends most of his time on missing persons and unsolved cases. Louisa Dunn's murder was eventually solved. Part 1 drops this Friday, August 8th. Part 2 the following Friday, August 15th. Kevin says it's a compelling story from a different angle than anything MMA has covered before. On the book front: Echo 1953, The Hollis Files Book 1, launched last Monday, July 27th, and is available on Amazon in Kindle format, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback ($14.99). Kevin walked through the writing process — four months in evenings around the podcast, feedback from his wife, a copy editor pass, and now out in the world. Early readers on Goodreads and Amazon have been enthusiastic. He's also already deep into drafting Book 2, which continues the story of Eli and Mari and their search for answers in the Lena Monroe case. A note on Witness Wednesday: Kevin is pausing WW while he rethinks the format. His interview with Crystal Dunahey was a difficult conversation, and it's not something he wants to continue doing casually. He says Witness Wednesday will be back — just in a different form. No return date announced. And the Halls of Mediocrity: find it on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube. New episodes every Tuesday. If you have information about Barbara Chapman's murder in Frankford, Ontario (January 23rd, 1984): OPP: 1-888-310-1122 Crime Stoppers (anonymous): 1-800-222-8477 A $50,000 reward from the Government of Ontario is available for information leading to an arrest and conviction. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon - Kindle, Kindle Unlimited, and paperback. Order your copy today. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. New episodes every Tuesday. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Substack | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E143
    July 31 · 19 min

    Cold Cases Don't Get Solved in a Lab. They Get Solved When Someone Finally Talks. | Barbara Chapman Part 2

    Part 1 covered January 23rd, 1984 — the ordinary morning, the phone call with her mother, the seven-hour window, the twelve-year-old daughter who found her in the garage. Barbara was 38 years old. Her murder has never been solved. Forty-two years later, no one has been charged. Part 2 is about what those 42 years actually looked like — and why the Ontario Provincial Police's behavior in the public record suggests this case is closer to resolution than the silence implies. There have been three public appeals. The first reward was offered in 2011 — $50,000 from the Government of Ontario — 27 years after the murder. Getting that reward requires the OPP to make the case to the provincial government that the investigation is still viable, that someone might still be reachable. They made that case. The reward was renewed and publicized again on the 40th anniversary in January 2024. Then came November 2024. And this is the one Kevin can't let go of. The OPP specifically appealed for witnesses from Northern Ontario — Sudbury, Thunder Bay, hundreds of kilometers from Frankford, where the murder occurred. Not a general anniversary appeal. A geographically targeted ask in a specific region that has nothing obvious to do with a 1984 crime scene in eastern Ontario. Investigators don't narrow their geographic focus without a reason. Three appeals over 13 years, and the third one looks completely different from the first two. That is investigative direction. Kevin also addresses why the OPP won't release details like the cause of death — and why that silence is strategy, not stonewalling. In cold cases where charges haven't been laid, investigators preserve specific details as a verification tool. Only someone with genuine knowledge of the crime could answer certain questions. The minute those details become public, that tool is gone. After 42 years, the OPP has maintained that discipline. That tells you something. On forensic technology: DNA profiling didn't exist as a criminal tool when Barbara was killed. Forensic genetic genealogy — the process of building a genetic profile from trace evidence and cross-referencing it against public ancestry databases like 23andMe or Ancestry.com — has since resolved cold cases going back to the 1950s. If biological evidence was preserved from the 1984 scene, the technology to potentially identify a contributor through their living relatives exists right now. (Kevin recommends following Othram Labs on X for the leading work in this field.) The RCMP's ViCLAS system, which cross-references violent crimes across Canadian agencies, has also been available to investigators for over 30 years. But here's Kevin's honest assessment: cold cases from the 1980s don't usually get solved because science catches up. They get solved because someone talks. Someone who was young in 1984 and is now in their 60s. Someone whose parent has since died, taking a secret with them that now has nowhere to go. Someone who got sober. Someone who finally decided the weight of carrying it is heavier than the consequences of sharing it. That is the realistic mechanism. And the Northern Ontario appeal is addressed directly to that person. Barbara Chapman's twelve-year-old daughter is now in her fifties. She has been living with what she found in that garage for her entire adult life. Barbara, her children, and the rest of her family should not have to wait any longer. If you have information about Barbara Chapman's murder: OPP tip line: 1-888-310-1122 Crime Stoppers (anonymous): 1-800-222-8477 A $50,000 reward from the Government of Ontario is available for information leading to an arrest and conviction. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Out now! Head on over to Amazon now and order! THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E142
    July 27 · 5 min

    Echo 1953 Is Live Today | Barbara Chapman: Why the OPP's Northern Ontario Plea Is a Big Deal | Mini

    Today is the day. Echo 1953, The Hollis Files Book 1, is officially available on Amazon. If you like crime fiction - a private investigator team working a difficult, layered case? Kevin promises it delivers. Every early reader so far has given it five stars, and Kevin is quick to note: he doesn't know any of them. Total strangers. Order on Amazon now. On the podcast front: we're between Barbara Chapman Part 1 and Part 2, which drops this Friday. If you haven't heard Part 1 yet, Frankford, Ontario, January 23rd, 1984, a 38-year-old mother murdered in her garage after her children left for school, 42 years unsolved, go listen before Friday. Kevin picks up this week on something worth sitting with before Part 2. The Ontario Provincial Police issued an appeal in November 2024 specifically targeting witnesses in Northern Ontario in connection with Barbara's murder. Barbara was killed in eastern Ontario. A geographically targeted witness appeal in Northern Ontario, 40 years after the fact, is not standard procedure. Law enforcement does not narrow their geographic focus without a reason. Kevin's read: they have a general idea of who is responsible and where that person lives today. That is his interpretation, not a statement from the OPP, but the specificity of that 2024 appeal is worth carrying into Part 2. Kevin also corrects the record from Part 1: Russell Williams was 20 years old, not 21, in January 1984. And he states this directly: he does not believe Williams is the perpetrator in Barbara's case, does not believe there is evidence to support it, and does not believe law enforcement believes it either. The Williams context is geographic proximity to one of the most prolific violent offenders in Canadian history, nothing more. Part 2 this Friday: the investigation, the 42-year paper trail, the $50,000 reward, the geography, and why the OPP still believes this case can be solved. On the Archive Podcast Network: the Halls of Mediocrity now has two episodes live, and Episode 3 drops tomorrow - the full story of two-time World Series champion Chad Curtis, convicted on six counts of criminal sexual conduct. Find it wherever you get your podcasts. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Available now on Amazon. Order your copy today. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E141
    July 24 · 17 min

    Someone Waited for Her Kids to Leave. Barbara Chapman Was Murdered in Frankford, Ontario. | Part 1

    On the morning of January 23rd, 1984, Barbara Chapman made breakfast for her two children in a small house north of Frankford, Ontario. She helped them get ready for school. She watched them board the school bus. Then she went inside and called her mother - they spoke while Barbara did chores around the house. That phone call was the last contact anyone had with Barbara Chapman alive. At four o'clock that afternoon, her twelve-year-old daughter came home from school. Her mother was not in the house. The girl searched for more than an hour. She eventually found her mother's body in the garage. Barbara Chapman was thirty-eight years old. Her murder has never been solved. Frankford is a small village on the shores of the Trent River in what is now the city of Quinte West in eastern Ontario, roughly 82 kilometers southeast of Peterborough and about 14 kilometers north of Trenton. In 1984 it had fewer than 2,000 people. The Canada Unsolved Database describes the morning this way: while Barbara prepared breakfast for her two children, someone was waiting. The cause of death has never been publicly released - a deliberate investigative decision. In cold cases, withholding specific details preserves the ability of investigators to evaluate tips and confessions. After 42 years, the OPP has maintained that discipline. What has been confirmed: Barbara was murdered, someone came to that house in the approximately seven hours between her phone call and her daughter's return, and no one has ever been charged. The Ontario Provincial Police have been investigating for 42 years. There have been anniversary appeals and a steadily increasing reward. In November 2024, the OPP issued a geographically targeted appeal for witnesses specifically in Northern Ontario - a narrowing of focus that is not accidental. Investigators do not make specific geographic asks without a reason. The current reward is $50,000 from the Government of Ontario, renewed and publicized on the 40th anniversary in January 2024. There is one name the public record associates with this region and this era that requires direct and careful address. Russell Williams was convicted in 2010 of the first-degree murders of Corporal Marie-France Comeau and Jessica Lloyd in eastern Ontario, as well as two sexual assaults and 82 break-and-enter offenses. CFB Trenton, the largest military airbase in Canada, which Williams commanded from July 2009 until his arrest, is approximately 14 kilometers from Frankford. In January 1984, when Barbara Chapman was murdered, Russell Williams was a student at the University of Toronto Scarborough. He had no documented connection to Frankford or Quinte West at that time and would not join the Canadian military until 1987. He has never been named as a suspect in Barbara's murder and has never been connected to the case through any forensic evidence. What the Williams context provides is geographic and chronological proximity, and the knowledge that investigators reviewing cases in this region after his 2010 arrest would have been aware of what happened in Frankford in 1984. Part 2 covers what investigators have done for four decades, what the $50,000 reward means, and why the OPP still believes this case can be solved. If you have information about Barbara Chapman's murder: OPP tip line: 1-888-310-1122 Crime Stoppers (anonymous): 1-800-222-8477 A $50,000 reward from the Government of Ontario is available for information leading to an arrest and conviction. ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Launches July 27, 2026 - just days away. Pre-order the Kindle version on Amazon now. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E140
    July 20 · 7 min

    A 1984 Murder in Ontario. Her Case Is Still Open. And Russell Williams Was in the Area. | MMA Mini

    I am on vacation — this was pre-recorded before he left, and the full episode schedule runs as normal in his absence. Two things this week. First: the Michael Dunahee series is complete. Part 1, the Witness Wednesday with his mother Crystal Dunahee, and Part 2 are all in your feed. I say out loud what listeners will likely have sensed: the conversation with Crystal was one of the hardest he has ever had. I walked away from that interview questioning whether I should have done it. Not because it wasn't well-intentioned — it was. But because there are conversations that require a different kind of experience than I have, and that interview brought that into focus. Witness Wednesday is not going away. I am rethinking who he invites into those specific conversations. Second: the next two-part series launches this Friday, and it is a departure from what MMA normally does. In 1984, in Ontario, a 38-year-old mother named Barbara Chapman had a morning that was completely ordinary by every measure. She woke her two children up. She made them breakfast. She got them to the school bus. She called her mother. Her mother would later describe the conversation as normal — nothing out of the ordinary. That afternoon, Barbara's 12-year-old daughter came home from school, looked around the house for over an hour, and then went to check the garage. She found her mother there, murdered. Barbara Chapman's case is 42 years old. The Ontario Provincial Police have never let it go dormant. There are regular fresh appeals for new information. It has never been solved. One of the more unusual aspects of Barbara's case is the geographic proximity to a name most Canadians will recognize. Russell Williams — decorated Air Force colonel, later convicted of two murders and multiple sexual assaults — was attending the University of Toronto Scarborough in 1984 and would have been in the region. He has never been publicly named as a suspect in Barbara's case. He has never been identified through any forensic evidence as a potential culprit. But the proximity has drawn attention, and it is a thread Kevin intends to examine. Part 1 this Friday. Part 2 the following Friday. Tips regarding Barbara Chapman's murder: Ontario Provincial Police / Crime Stoppers: 1-800-222-TIPS (8477) ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Launching July 27, 2026. Pre-order on Amazon now. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. Now live on the Archive Podcast Network. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E139
    July 17 · 16 min

    Michael Dunahee Part 2: 11,000 Tips, A Case Hampered by Its Era, and Why This Case Could Still Be Solved

    Part 1 covered the afternoon of March 24th, 1991 — the playground, the fifty people who saw nothing, the boy who was there and then wasn't. Part 2 picks up where that left off, with 35 years of investigation, the leads that closed without answers, and where the case stands in 2026. The investigation that followed Michael Dunahee's disappearance was one of the largest missing child responses in Canadian history. Nearly 100 officers from agencies across British Columbia were mobilized within days. The FBI provided support. America's Most Wanted covered the case multiple times. And the tip system they built on the fly — tips written on carbon paper, sorted by hand — crashed under the weight of calls before a dedicated line could be established. Victoria Police have since acknowledged that if modern technology had existed in 1991 — video surveillance, computerized tip management, advanced DNA analysis — the case might have been solved in those first few days. It was not a failure of effort. It was a description of the environment. In 2009, police in Milwaukee searched the home of a man named Vernon Seitz — a 62-year-old who had confessed to his psychiatrist that he killed a child in 1959 and had knowledge of another killing. When they searched the home, they found child pornography, files on missing children cases from the late 1980s and 1990s, and a missing person poster of Michael Dunahee. Alongside the poster: a map labeled "Mill Stream Park," north of Victoria. Victoria Police were contacted. Before the connection could be fully resolved, Seitz was found dead, apparently of natural causes. No definitive link to Michael was ever established. DNA tests in 2006, 2011, and 2013 each ruled out men who bore physical similarities to Michael. A tip through a Vancouver Canucks fan forum in 2013 led investigators to Surrey. On September 9, 2013, VicPD confirmed that man was not Michael either. 11,000 tips. Multiple serious DNA leads. Not one confirmed connection. Kevin covers the Amber Alert question directly — what the system requires, why it would not have applied to Michael's case, and what that means. He draws the parallel to Morgan Nick, who disappeared from a little league parking lot in Arkansas in 1995 under strikingly similar circumstances — a public place, a parent nearby, no witnesses, no resolution. And he explains what Child Find BC is, what Crystal Dunahee built from it, and what the annual Keep the Hope Alive Fund Run in Esquimalt means to the Victoria community. The case is still open. A detective is still assigned. And the tools available to investigators in 2026 are categorically different from 1991: forensic genetic genealogy, advanced facial recognition, and the ability to digitally cross-reference 11,000 tips in ways that were impossible when they were written on carbon paper. Michael Dunahee would be 40 years old today. His family has never given up hope. If you have information about Michael Dunahee's disappearance: Victoria Police Department tip line: 250-995-7444 Online tips: vicpd.ca ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Launching July 27, 2026. Pre-order on Amazon now. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. Launching July 14, 2026. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

  • S4 · E138
    July 15 · 16 min

    Thirty-Five Years of Searching and Advocacy for Michael Dunahee | Crystal Dunahee | WW

    On March 24th, 1991, Crystal Dunahee drove to a women's flag football game in Victoria, British Columbia. Michael — her four-year-old son with blonde hair, blue eyes, and freckles — asked if he could play at the park. She looked. There were a couple of kids already there. It was a normal Sunday afternoon. She said yes. It was the first time she had ever let him go to the park by himself. When his father Bruce walked to the playground minutes later, Michael was gone. In this Witness Wednesday, Crystal Dunahee sits down with Kevin to share who Michael was — not the case, not the timeline, but the boy. The four-year-old who was learning to ride his bike without training wheels and had taken a wipeout. Who was getting ready for kindergarten in September. Who was so excited about his baby sister Caitlin, who had just been born six months earlier. Who was a trusting, innocent kid who would follow his friends into the trees and come home covered in rashes from the spiders. Crystal talks about what that afternoon looked like from where she was standing. About the investigation that followed — one of the largest missing child responses in Canadian history — and what it was like to go through it as a mother while also being questioned as part of the family investigation that every case requires. About the toll of 35 years of leads and dead ends, and why the detectives eventually stopped telling the family every detail of every tip — not because they stopped working, but because the emotional weight of each false lead was too much. She talks about Caitlin, who grew up living in the shadow of her brother's disappearance, seeing herself as an only child. She talks about the 2021 age-enhanced sketch of Michael at 34 — and how strange it is to watch your child age through a forensic artist's rendering instead of through life. She talks about Child Find BC, the advocacy organization she helped bring back from dormancy — the Hope Alive run, the education work, the belief that the conversation about personal safety with children has to start young and be repeated often. If something doesn't feel right, trust your body. Those are her words. And when Kevin asks what she thinks happened that day, Crystal says what she has said for 35 years: wrong place, wrong time. And when he asks what she would say to Michael — wherever he is — she says: we never gave up hope. That motherly instinct. He's out there. It's just a matter of time for something to trigger, to make him realize this is not who I am. This is who I am. **If you have information about Michael Dunahee's disappearance: ** Victoria Police Department tip line: 250-995-7400 ext. 44 Online: vicpd.ca ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE Launching July 27, 2026. Pre-order on Amazon now. THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away. Launching July 14, 2026. Find us wherever you get your podcasts. MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday. midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon Follow us: X | Facebook Group Thanks to our monthly supporters jared K Lisa Mooney Jamie Mcconnell ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

Showing 1–20 of 22 episodes