
Why LGBTQ Catholics Still Seek Conversion Therapy with Eve Tushnet
In the latest Mezzo episode, I talk with author and Building Catholic Futures co-founder Eve Tushnet to ask the question: why do LGBTQ+ Catholics seek out conversion therapy? What emotional and spiritual pressures drive Catholics to the practice? And why does simply saying “it doesn’t work” fail to deter vulnerable LGBTQ+ Catholics from seeking it? We also dive into Eve’s story of converting to Catholicism, navigating life as a Gay Catholic, the “side A / side B” discourse in Christian spaces, and much more. I’m very excited to share this conversation with you! 00:00 Building Catholic Futures 02:33 Catholic Convert Backstory 06:31 Blogging and Public Voice 12:47 Why Conversion Therapy Appeals 20:52 Hidden Harms and Aftermath 25:09 Sexuality Change Claims 26:14 Beyond Born This Way 26:48 Stories Over Orientation Fixes 30:21 Pastoral Care Next Steps 33:12 Integrated Gay Catholic Life 51:42 Building Catholic Futures