The Devils Bathtub: The Murder of Craig Rideout
The early morning of Wednesday, July 20th, 2016. Yates County, New York, in the rolling farm country of the Finger Lakes. A Mennonite farmer is riding his bicycle to work down a quiet country road in the town of Jerusalem. And just off the road, at the edge of the woods, he sees something that doesn't belong there. A bundle. Wrapped in a tarp. Inside is a man. He's been strangled. He's been beaten so badly his face is fractured. And someone has poured drain cleaner, the industrial-strength kind, over his face and his hands. To burn away his features. To burn away his fingerprints. So that no one would ever know who he was. It almost worked. Join Patreon here to binge bonus content! Crime Curious is creating a kick-ass exclusive listener experience | Patreon Want to just donate to the show? You can do so here: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/crimecurious Music By: Michael Drzewiecki Cover Art By: Charnell Sources Craig Wallace Rideout obituary, Democrat and Chronicle via Legacy.com (2016) 13WHAM: Investigators say Craig Rideout was killed in his basement (2016) AP via Fox News: Father of 7 was killed inside his New York home 13WHAM: Medical examiner testifies in Rideout trial NY1: Mother, son found guilty in Rideout trial (2017) AP via Fox News: Mom and son convicted Justia: People v Rideout (Laura), Appellate Division (2019) Justia: People v Rideout (Colin), Appellate Division (2024) Spectrum News: Laura Rideout appeals, blames sons (2019) 13WHAM: Court denies Laura Rideout's appeal (2019) WHEC: Laura Rideout appeal for new trial denied Democrat and Chronicle via Yahoo: See No Evil episode; where they are now (2023) Soap Central: Dateline "Devil's Bathtub" recap Sportskeeda: Craig Rideout case details 13WHAM: Rideout case back in court (911 call, garrote, keys, Diet Coke) CBS News: Wife, sons accused of cleaning up blood (tip about suspicious activity) Rochester First: Crime lab testimony on bloody clothes from the trunk Rochester First: Sons pulled over with rifle and knife; keys on the bed The Cinemaholic: Phone trace, emails, square-edged shovel WHEC: The Colin Rideout interview 13WHAM: Juror on why we couldn't convict Paul Tucci 13WHAM: Paul Tucci sits down after acquittal (Colin's statement) Rochester First: Paul Tucci talks about his acquittal Spectrum News: "It just didn't feel real"