Skip to content
Artwork for LessWrong (30+ Karma)
LessWrong (30+ Karma) · Today · 8 min

“No comment” by DirectedEvolution

We've noticed that LessWrong has been declining and is saturated with content about AI. There are many hypotheses explaining this decline: community maturity; competition with Substack, AI chat, and old posts; that we're a victim of our own success as our ideas have entered the water supply; an eternal september effect as the AI boom drives new participants who come for the AI, not the rationality. I suspect they're all part of the problem. One solution has been to pay writers for posts. LW has prizes and a culture of commissioning posts or reviews out of personal funds, and now Inkhaven. My experience of having received commissions is that they didn't produce my best work. In fact, I think the consistent pattern is that people would approach me because of the posts I wrote for free that they liked, offer me money to write a post catered to their interests, and then feel disappointed that the content or quality wasn't what they were hoping for, or that the post didn't get more karma. I genuinely appreciate their generosity and willingness to take a risk on my writing. However, that disappointment was one of the nails in the coffin for [...] --- Outline: (01:36) LessWrong's top authors comment less on each others' posts than they did in the past (04:11) Paying for posts: too little money, too much pressure (05:53) Takeaway: rebuild the LessWrong comments --- First published: November 20th, 2026 Source: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/9e2nh92HurD7bWJMR/no-comment --- Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

0:00-8:11

transcript

No transcript — this publisher did not publish one.

show notes

We've noticed that LessWrong has been declining and is saturated with content about AI. There are many hypotheses explaining this decline: community maturity; competition with Substack, AI chat, and old posts; that we're a victim of our own success as our ideas have entered the water supply; an eternal september effect as the AI boom drives new participants who come for the AI, not the rationality. I suspect they're all part of the problem.

One solution has been to pay writers for posts. LW has prizes and a culture of commissioning posts or reviews out of personal funds, and now Inkhaven. My experience of having received commissions is that they didn't produce my best work. In fact, I think the consistent pattern is that people would approach me because of the posts I wrote for free that they liked, offer me money to write a post catered to their interests, and then feel disappointed that the content or quality wasn't what they were hoping for, or that the post didn't get more karma. I genuinely appreciate their generosity and willingness to take a risk on my writing. However, that disappointment was one of the nails in the coffin for [...]

---

Outline:

(01:36) LessWrong's top authors comment less on each others' posts than they did in the past

(04:11) Paying for posts: too little money, too much pressure

(05:53) Takeaway: rebuild the LessWrong comments

---

First published:
November 20th, 2026

Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/9e2nh92HurD7bWJMR/no-comment

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

links2